If You Want Hight Credit Scores, Don’t Leave Open Credit Card Accounts Unused
I received a question from one of my readers to this blog and I thought it was relevant enough for all of my readers to see and learn from.
Dear Mark,
I have four major credit card accounts in my name. I use one of them for my work expenses, one for household expenses, a Cabela’s card which I like for the points, and another one that I don’t use much. It has a zero balance. Does this hurt my FICO scores by having a zero activity and zero balance? Will it hurt my credit score more if I close the account?
Sherry M. Austin, TX
Hello Sherry,
Thanks for writing in. I have a short answer for you to your question….if your main goal is to keep your current high scores, you should leave the account open, but you must start USING the card! Keep the activity small so that you don’t boost up your credit utilization.
You don’t want the bank to cancel the card because you are not using it. Remember, the banks are in business to make money, if they have given you a product and they aren’t making any money, then they may make a decision to close it. As you know this will hurt your scores because your available credit ratios will change.
Regardless of who closes the account, your credit score may fall due to a change in a key credit scoring ratio. “Closing an account causes you to lose the available credit limit associated with it. Your utilization rate, also called your balance-to-limit ratio, will increase as a result of closing the account. That may cause a temporary decline in your credit scores.
To get an idea of how your utilization ratio could be impacted by closing an account, let’s say each of your four cards has a credit limit of $1,000, for a combined total of $4,000 in available credit. Let’s also say that across those four accounts, you’ve got a total debt burden of $2,000. Then your unused card gets closed, taking your available credit down to just $3,000. Now, instead of using 50 percent of your credit lines, you’re suddenly using about 66 percent of your total available credit. That higher proportion makes you appear to be a riskier borrower, since you’re that much closer to maxing out your available credit.
Your credit score should reflect that change, although the actual scoring damage will vary from borrower to borrower. The FICO score assesses all the information on your credit report. So the score impact from any one action, such as closing an account, will depend on what other information is present on the credit report.
Stay tuned,
Your Credit Repair Expert
Mark
